African cichlids from Lake Malawi and Lake Tanganyika are two of the most popular freshwater fish species in the aquarium hobby, known for their bright colors and fascinating behaviors. However, keeping them together in one tank requires careful planning. These cichlids originate from different lakes with distinct water chemistry and environmental conditions, which can make it challenging to create a shared habitat that meets their needs.
In this article, we’ll explore whether you can successfully keep Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids together, and provide guidelines on compatibility, tank setup, and water chemistry to ensure a healthy environment for both types of fish.
Compatibility: Can Malawi and Tanganyikan Cichlids Coexist?
While it is possible to keep Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids in the same tank, there are several factors to consider to ensure compatibility. These include temperament, diet, and tank space.
1. Temperament and Aggression Levels
- Malawi cichlids (such as Mbuna, Peacocks, and Haps) are known for their territorial and often aggressive behavior. They are especially aggressive during breeding, which can lead to conflict if housed with more peaceful fish.
- Tanganyikan cichlids (such as Julidochromis, Frontosa, and Neolamprologus) tend to be more reserved but can still be territorial, especially when it comes to defending their nesting sites.
Solution: To minimize aggression, it’s important to provide plenty of territories and hiding places. Use rock formations, caves, and other structures to allow each species to claim its own space. Mixing species with similar aggression levels is also a good idea—avoid keeping overly aggressive Malawi cichlids with peaceful Tanganyikan species.
2. Size and Diet Compatibility
- Diet: Most Malawi cichlids, particularly Mbuna, are herbivores, feeding primarily on algae and plant matter. Tanganyikan cichlids, on the other hand, have more varied diets—ranging from carnivorous to omnivorous species.
Solution: It’s important to provide a varied diet that caters to both. For Malawi cichlids, focus on spirulina-based foods and vegetable matter, while offering more protein-rich foods like brine shrimp and krill for the Tanganyikan cichlids.
3. Tank Size and Space
- Both Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids are territorial, so adequate tank space is crucial. A minimum of 75 gallons is recommended for mixed setups, but larger tanks are better to avoid overcrowding and territorial disputes.
Solution: Provide plenty of rocks and caves to create defined territories for each fish. The more space and hiding spots, the less likely aggression will become an issue.
Getting the Water Chemistry Right for Malawi and Tanganyikan Cichlids
One of the biggest challenges in keeping Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids together is water chemistry. Both species thrive in alkaline, hard water, but the specific parameters can vary slightly between the two lakes.
1. pH Levels
- Lake Malawi cichlids prefer a pH of 7.8 to 8.6.
- Lake Tanganyika cichlids thrive in a slightly higher pH range, usually between 8.0 and 9.0.
Solution: To keep both species happy, aim for a pH range of 8.0 to 8.5, which falls within the acceptable limits for both Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids. This can be achieved by adding crushed coral or aragonite sand to the substrate or filter to raise and buffer the pH.
2. Water Hardness
- Malawi cichlids do well in water with a general hardness (GH) of 4–6 dGH and a carbonate hardness (KH) of 6–8 dKH.
- Tanganyikan cichlids, on the other hand, prefer harder water, with GH levels of 11–17 dGH and KH around 16–19 dKH.
Solution: To balance the water hardness for both species, you can add cichlid salts or commercial mineral supplements that replicate the mineral content of the lakes. These supplements typically contain calcium, magnesium, and other trace elements that increase water hardness. While Tanganyikan cichlids require slightly harder water, keeping the GH between 8–12 dGH and KH around 10–12 dKH will satisfy both species.
3. Temperature
Both Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids thrive in warm water, with similar temperature ranges:
- Lake Malawi cichlids: 23°C to 28°C (73°F to 82°F)
- Lake Tanganyika cichlids: 24°C to 29°C (75°F to 84°F)
Solution: Maintain a consistent temperature between 25°C and 27°C (77°F to 80°F) to accommodate both species. A reliable heater and thermometer are essential to keep the water within this range.
Tank Setup for Malawi and Tanganyikan Cichlids
Creating the right environment is key to keeping both species happy. Here are some important considerations for tank setup:
1. Rocky Structures and Caves
Both Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids are accustomed to rocky environments, where they can establish territories and seek shelter. Tanganyikan cichlids, in particular, are substrate spawners and may require caves for breeding.
Solution: Use a combination of limestone rocks, slate, and ceramic caves to build a natural environment. Ensure there are enough hiding places to allow each fish to claim its territory. Malawi cichlids tend to favor rocky formations, while many Tanganyikan species prefer small caves or cracks in the substrate.
2. Substrate
For a shared tank, a substrate of crushed coral, aragonite, or cichlid-specific sand will help buffer the water and keep pH and hardness levels stable. These substrates will also mimic the natural habitats of both Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids.
3. Filtration
Both species produce a significant amount of waste, so a powerful filtration system is essential. Aim for a filter that can handle at least 4 to 5 times the tank’s volume per hour. High-quality mechanical, biological, and chemical filtration will ensure good water quality and prevent spikes in ammonia and nitrites.
Solution: Consider using a canister filter or a combination of hang-on-back (HOB) filters for effective filtration. You may also want to add an air stone or powerhead to increase oxygen levels, as these cichlids thrive in well-oxygenated water.
Final Thoughts: Can You Keep Malawi and Tanganyikan Cichlids Together?
While it’s possible to keep Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids in the same tank, doing so requires careful attention to water chemistry, tank setup, and compatibility. By maintaining a pH between 8.0–8.5, keeping the water hardness around 8–12 dGH, and providing plenty of space and hiding spots, you can create a shared environment that meets the needs of both species.
Remember to choose species with similar aggression levels, provide a varied diet to suit both herbivorous and omnivorous needs, and ensure your filtration system is up to the task of maintaining clean, healthy water. With the right balance, you can enjoy the beauty of both Malawi and Tanganyikan cichlids coexisting in a single aquarium.
Leave a Reply